How Economic Uncertainty Is Changing Consumer Behavior—and How Brands Can Adapt

Key Takeaways:

• Today's market is a value economy: Consumers aren't spending significantly less—only about a 1% dip is forecast for the second half of 2026—but they are buying more deliberately.
• Scrutiny of discretionary purchases is the defining consumer behavior: Shoppers are looking harder for reasons to justify non-essential buys.
• Messaging adjustment is where most teams should focus: For most categories, the audience and media mix can hold steady. Value-based messaging that justifies a premium or creates urgency is what gives cautious consumers a reason to buy.
• Protect brand marketing through the downturn: Leaning into performance marketing is understandable when budgets face scrutiny, but teams that cut brand marketing investments for too long will eventually tap out the market.

The economy is weighing on consumers.

Amidst an uncertain job market, persistent inflation, and ongoing geopolitical tensions, consumer sentiment has taken a hit. In the second quarter of 2026, the share of US consumers feeling optimistic about the economy fell to its lowest point in two years.

Despite the hardship, market conditions have not translated to a recession economy—at least as of yet—as consumer spending is forecast to dip only about 1% in the second half of the year. The US ad market also remains strong, with ad spend projected to grow by 9.5% in 2026 (and those gains aren't just a byproduct of political, Olympics, and World Cup spending).

All together, today’s market looks more like a value economy: Consumers are spending more cautiously and taking the time to hunt for the best deals. For advertisers, understanding how to adjust campaign strategies in response is key to success.

How the 2026 Economy Is Changing Consumer Spending

While consumer financial wellbeing remains resilient, economic concerns are impacting discretionary purchases, with a larger share of consumers planning to spend less on nonessential items and experiences over the next few months than last quarter.

That caution runs deepest among lower-income households. However, higher- and middle-income consumers reported the steepest declines in optimism in Q2, with many reconsidering their "nice-to-haves." Given that groceries cost about a third more than they did in 2019, with housing and family health insurance up by even greater proportions, the rising cost of “must-haves” is putting pressure on the budget consumers otherwise reserve for wants.

That shift is already showing up in consumer spending, with retail sales slipping in July for the first time in nine months.

Increased caution around discretionary spending will likely play out in a few different ways. Some consumers will postpone purchases, weighing whether their old phone or car can last another six months. Others will make trade-offs rather than cut spending, hunting for the best value they can find across categories like travel, retail, and clothing. And some will forego certain purchases entirely, deciding a nonessential isn't worth the money right now.

The common thread is that consumers are scrutinizing discretionary purchases and looking harder for reasons to justify their spending—which means it's on advertisers to supply that justification.

How Should Advertisers Adjust Their Media and Messaging Amidst Economic Uncertainty?

Economy-related shifts in consumer sentiment and behavior should inform brands' messaging more than their media strategies. For most categories, the audience and media mix don't need to change when consumers grow cautious. By adjusting messaging, however, brands can give discerning consumers the justification they need to make a purchase.

Considering this, value-based messaging is key. As consumers evaluate cheaper alternatives, brands should make the case for their premium—for example, by showing how their product outperforms or outlasts competitors’. And as consumers consider postponing purchases, brands should give them clear reasons to buy now, such as a limited-time offer.

Brand vs. Performance Marketing: What's the Right Mix in a Downturn?

As consumers have grown more cautious, many brands have done the same. I’ve seen some begin gravitating more towards performance marketing, seeking measurable returns that make investments more easily defensible.

Leaning harder into performance makes sense when budgets are under scrutiny and marketers need to demonstrate ROI. But pulling back on brand marketing for too long tends to backfire. When brands don’t continuously generate demand at the top of the funnel, they eventually run out of prospects to convert lower down. History bears this out: Brands that pull back on spending during economic downturns tend to fare worse, while brands that keep investing tend to come out ahead. Even outside of a downturn, one study found that shifting from a performance-focused strategy to a more balanced mix of performance and brand delivered a median revenue ROI increase of 90%.

The risks that come with cutting brand investment are particularly acute for premium brands. A brand that stops making the case for its premium leaves consumers to make purchase decisions based on cost alone—a risky position when value is top of mind. Sustained brand investment is what keeps consumers perceiving a certain brand as worth the premium, even with cheaper alternatives available.

How to Advertise Effectively Through Economic Uncertainty in 2026

Inflation, geopolitical unrest, and job market uncertainty are changing how consumers spend in 2026. The brands that navigate this period most successfully will be those that meet a more cautious consumer with value-focused messaging and factor in the risks of pulling back on brand marketing for too long.

As economic and geopolitical conditions continue to shift, the brands that keep a pulse on what’s top of mind for consumers will be best positioned to earn their dollars.

—

Want more timely digital advertising content delivered straight to your inbox? Basis’ Scout newsletter helps leaders stay up to date on the trends, research, and perspectives shaping the industry.